chemistry question #11

Kaycie Nabeta, a 16 year old female from the Internet asks on May 10, 1999,


Can you explain where the "extra" ATP comes from in photosynthesis? As I understand it:

  • 24 ATP come out of the light reaction (12 water molecules times 2 ATP -- one from the pair of hydrogens from photolysis, the other from the pair transported by plastoquinone)
  • 18 ATP are used in the Calvin cycle/dark reaction/carbon fixation (6 cycles times 2 ATP when PGA changes into PGAL plus 6 cycles times 1 ATP when ribulose phosphate changes into ribulose diphosphate)
  • Therefore, 24-18=8 ATP
But 36 ATP are supposed to come out of photosynthesis (because 36 ATP are formed in cellular respiration) Where did the rest of the ATP come from?

viewed 13310 times

the answer

Gary Brudvig answered on May 10, 1999, A:

There is not a fixed number of ATP molecules made in the light reactions of photosynthesis because both non-cyclic electron transport (through both photosystems I and II) and cyclic electron transport (though only photosystem I) can occur. The extent of cyclic (ATP forming) and non-cyclic (ATP and NADPH forming) is regulated to balance the amount of ATP and NADPH needed.

Add to or comment on this answer using the form below.
(required if you would like a response)
Note: All submissions are moderated prior to posting.
If you found this answer useful, please consider making a small donation to