earth sciences and ecology question #2857

Barbara Pearson, a 42 year old female from Holly Springs, NC asks on July 27, 2005,


I was reading a text which stated that scientists have used ice cores to calculate prehistoric CO2 levels and temperatures. I can understand how they might be able to determine the CO2 levels from the cores, but how could they determine average temperatures based on the cores?

viewed 15081 times

the answer

Dan Marshall, professor of geochemistry, Simon Fraser University, Canada answered on August 2, 2005, A:

There are a few ways to measure ancient temperatures (or paleotemperatures) from ice cores. The most widely used method is to measure the oxygen (abbreviated O) isotope ratios within the ice cores. The two isotopes of oxygen used are oxygen-18 and oxygen-16. This measurement is generally performed on the ice (H2O) from the ice cores, but could also utilize the CO2 extracted from the ice cores. The 18O/16O ratio from the ice is measured and then converted to a delta 18O value. The delta (or "difference") 18O value is an expression of the 18O/16O ratio relative to some international oxygen isotope reference material.

It basically has to do with vibrational energies and their effects on bond breaking and formation. My rule of thumb is that there is more of the heavy isotope in the denser phase of a reaction as temperature increases. So as glacial ice comes from snow, which is precipitated from water vapour...

H2O (v) <==> H2O (s)

In this case the solid is the more dense phase, so at lower temperatures it will have less of the heavier isotope (18) and relatively more of the lighter (16) to reflect a sluggishness of the heavier isotope to react at lower temperatures. This by the way is pretty much independent of the amount of global precipitation.

In general the delta 18O value indicates whether the paleotemperature is higher or lower relative to current temperatures. For example more negative (or smaller) delta 18O values indicate colder conditions and more positive (or larger) delta 18O values.

Add to or comment on this answer using the form below.
(required if you would like a response)
Note: All submissions are moderated prior to posting.
If you found this answer useful, please consider making a small donation to