Biology Question #2925
Jim, a 30 year old male from Philadelphia asks on September 12, 2005,
Why doesn't a person lose 9 lb when they consume 1 litre of ice water? If a calorie is the energy it takes to raise 1 cc of water 1 deg C then to raise 1000cc's from 0C to 33C would require 33,000 calories. I'm lead to believe that you must expend 3600 calories to lose 1 lb of body weight. Ignoring the temporary gain of 2.2 lbs water weight, why doesn't drinking 1 litre of ice water result in an expenditure of the caloric equivalent of 9 pounds of weight?
viewed 16840 times
answered on September 12, 2005
There's an important confusion you need to clear up in this question: the calories used to describe the energy content of food are actually KILOcalories, that is, one food calorie is enough to raise 1 cc of water by 1000 degrees C, not by 1 degree. So to lose 9 lb of weight on the proposed plan, you'd need to drink 1,000 litres of ice water, which would be very uncomfortable and possibly dangerous.
[Editor: To put it another way, your scheme might work, but you are off by a factor of 1000. Hence, in the perfect case, drinking one litre of ice water would lower your weight by .009 pounds, or 0.14 ounces, which is about 4 grams--almost insignificant compared to the 2.2lb of water. That would be the answer if there was no other source of heat but calories in body fat. In reality, many of those calories would come from the ambient environment, not from burning fat, so you'd probably actually lose about a gram of weight by drinking a litre of ice water. A paper clip weighs about one gram.]
Add to or comment on this answer using the form below.
Note: All submissions are moderated prior to posting.
If you found this answer useful, please consider making a small donation to science.ca.