Chemistry Question #41

nohjin, a 28 year old male from the Internet asks on August 4, 1999,

Where does the energy in freezing water come from? When water freezes, its volume increases so that it has enough "energy" to break a sealed jar full of water in the freezer. I can imagine extremely strong materials such as granite having little cracks where water might seep in and when the water freezes, it can break up even hard rock. My question is where does this "energy" come from? And what would happen if you put the water in a container which could not break or change in size or volume, and tried to freeze the water?

viewed 14902 times

The answer

Barry Shell answered on August 4, 1999

The basic answer to your question lies in the angle of the bonds in an H2O molecule. The molecule has an oxygen at the centre and two hydrogens that come out at either end forming a 104.5 degree angle. Other websites have some excellent pictures and explanations of water shape. This gives water most of its amazing properties. When it freezes, this angle opens up a bit to create approximately tetrahedral crystals that give the characteristic hexagonal shape to ice crystals. The ideal angle for a tetrahedron is 109.47 degrees, but in real life ice it turns out to be closer to 108 degrees. This 'opening up' is what makes ice less dense than liquid water. The energy that you are wondering about is the energy in the H-O bonds. There is some benefit energy-wise for the water molecules in a solid (ice) to open up somewhat, making the angle just a bit wider than what it is in liquid water. Now ice as we know it is only one form of crystalline water. There are at least 9 forms and maybe more. When you confine the water in a vessel as you describe, effectively increasing the pressure on the water as it freezes you would force a different phase of water. You have to look at a phase diagram for water and find the corresponding temperature and pressure to see what phase to expect. You can find example phase diagrams at this University of Southhampton website. Also have a look at this website created by a professor at Caltech which gives a good explanation of the physical properties of ice.

Add to or comment on this answer using the form below.

Note: All submissions are moderated prior to posting.

If you found this answer useful, please consider making a small donation to