physics question #761

Andre Szalinski, a 67 year old male from Doussard, France asks on April 20, 2002,


In my youth, I heard a story about an experiment: you compress a metallic spring and you put it in an acid which dissolves the spring. What happened to the energy stored in the spring?

viewed 16806 times

the answer

Barry Shell answered on April 21, 2002, A:

A quick web search at yielded the answer. The energy goes to heat the acid slightly. Here is what I found at a website debunking perpetual motion machines called Go Ask Grandpa:

"Here is the attempt: Begin with two identical springs. Compress one of them and bind it with leather strapping. Note that there is potential energy in the compressed spring that is not in the other spring. Now - put each spring in an identical beaker of acid that will dissolve the springs, but not the leather. Now both springs are gone. What happened to that potential energy in the compressed spring? Did we destroy it?

The answer came later with a more careful experiment. The experiment was performed in a calorimeter. This is an insulated tank that keeps track of the heat so that none or nearly none is lost. It was found that the acid that dissolved the compressed spring got hotter than the acid that dissolved the uncompressed spring, and the extra heat was exactly the amount to account for the potential energy stored in the compressed spring. This was an amazing result at that time, and it well supported the conservation law."

Add to or comment on this answer using the form below.
(required if you would like a response)
Note: All submissions are moderated prior to posting.
If you found this answer useful, please consider
making a small donation to