biology question #8629

Richard Dinning, a 67 year old male from Mississauga asks on November 8, 2011,


What would happen, given the loss of polar ice and it's deleterious affect on polar bears, if we rounded up a few dozen males and females and dropped them off on the norther tip of Antarctica? As far as I know the only predators currently there are seals and whales, nothing land based.

viewed 4731 times

the answer

Andrew E. Derocher, Biology professor, University of Alberta answered on November 9, 2011, A:

Polar bears would do wonderfully in the Antarctic.  They would, however, devastate the seals and penguins that live there. Some penguin species such Adelie penguins are also doing poorly with changing Antarctic sea ice, but others like chinstrap penguins are doing very well.  

Overall, polar bears need seal blubber for energy and there is lots of seal species in Antarctica.  The seals and penguins are totally naive to surface predators and would likely be very easy prey (probably like ringed seals were when polar bears first evolved and moved onto the sea ice).

There is an international treaty that would preclude introduction of species to Antarctica so we'd have to change that. In general, conservation biologists don't move species to new areas where they don't already exist, because it often leads to more problems and new endangered species.

Add to or comment on this answer using the form below.
(required if you would like a response)
Note: All submissions are moderated prior to posting.
If you found this answer useful, please consider
making a small donation to